Health Care In The States

Insurance Agents Key To California Success Enrolling Asian-Americans

By Lisa Aliferis, KQED

March 25th, 2014, 5:00 AM

While Latino enrollment has lagged in California’s insurance marketplace, Asians have signed up in numbers outstripping their representation in the pool of eligible people.  According to new Covered California data, the overwhelming majority of Chinese, Korean and Vietnamese enrollees are buying plans through certified insurance agents, as opposed to community groups or the Covered California website.

A Covered California brochure in Chinese.

There is no charge to consumers who work with agents, whose commissions are paid by insurance companies.

Since January, Asians have been enrolling in strong numbers. People of Asian descent make up about 14 percent of California’s eligible pool, according to estimates compiled by the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research and the UC Berkeley Labor Center. Asians reached that target straight out of the gate, making up 13.5 percent of all enrollees by January. They have surged from there. In the most recent data from Covered California, which comprised enrollment from Oct. 1 to Feb. 28, Asians made up 22.9 percent of all enrollees.

Licensed insurance brokers can sell customers plans on the Covered California marketplace, but they must first be specially certified to do so. Covered California says 40 percent of its total Covered California enrollments are coming via these certified insurance agents. But within certain Asian sub-populations, the percentage is much higher, Covered California says:

  • 57 percent of Chinese enrollments are through certified insurance agents (CIAs)
  • 65 percent of Vietnamese enrollments are through CIAs
  • 70 percent of Korean enrollments are through CIAs

These numbers “suggest that the Asian agents are a driving force in helping Covered CA exceed our enrollment goal in Asian communities,” Wendy McAnelly, a public information officer for Covered California, said in an email.

This information was not a big surprise to Simon Chew. He runs Ehealth-Plans, an insurance business with four offices in San Francisco. All his agents are trilingual — in English, Mandarin and Cantonese. Chew estimates he’s signed up 2,000 people since the Covered California marketplace opened last October, and half of them were uninsured. He sees a difference between how Caucasians shop and how his clients — overwhelmingly Chinese Americans and Chinese immigrants — shop. While what he calls the “mainstream market” is comfortable purchasing insurance online, those of Chinese descent want to do business face-to-face, with someone of a similar background.

“That’s how, culturally, Asians do business,” Chew said. “They like to stick to their own kind because of communication convenience.” Chew also complained that too much Covered California advertising is focused on the website, as opposed to letting people know that local insurance agents could also help them.

Covered California did not have enrollment information broken down by type for Latinos — who make up nearly half of the marketplace’s potential pool but who account for only 22 percent of all enrollees. Covered California has been faulted for its missteps in signing up Latinos.

Unlike Asians, Latinos are generally not familiar with health insurance as a product, so this can make sign-ups more difficult.

That lack of familiarity with health insurance may stretch to the broker community, too. Covered California has slightly more certified brokers who speak an Asian language than who speak Spanish — 15.31 percent vs. 15.06 percent — yet Spanish speakers outnumber those who speak an Asian language. About 29 percent of Californians speak Spanish, while just about 10 percent speak an Asian or Pacific Island language, according to census data.

Overall successful enrollment may hide gaps

But Asians are not a monolithic group, advocates caution. Doreena Wong is with Advancing Justice in Los Angeles. Her group oversees the single statewide collaborative of community groups that handles outreach to Asians to encourage enrollment on Covered California. She was surprised by the success that brokers have had compared with community groups. “I am surprised that is as high as it is,” Wong said. “I don’t know if that means that most of the enrollees in these communities are English-speaking.”

Community groups have long worried that those with limited-English skills would be left out of Covered California. Wong is concerned that certain immigrant groups who have less experience with insurance or universal health care in their home countries would be harder to reach. “The united Cambodian community, Indian, Pakistani,” she said, “We don’t know what the numbers are for those particular sub-groups.”

Yeri Shon, of the Korean Community Center of the East Bay in Oakland, said her group has had great success in signing up the “monolingual” clients she serves. There’s universal health care in Korea, so people are already comfortable with the concept of the government helping out.

But she’s heard from advocates who say they are having a harder time. “The Tongan community leader says teaching the idea of insurance is very difficult,” Shon said. “In Tonga, people apparently only go to the hospital when they are really sick.”

Mixed-status families a barrier to enrollment

While President Barack Obama has insisted that undocumented relatives of people who sign up for insurance will not be deported, many advocates think this is still a barrier, especially for Latinos. Yet there are almost certainly undocumented Asian immigrants as well, and there does not seem to be the same level of fear. Wong believes that there may be a higher percentage of mixed-status Latino families than Asian families. “That fear may not be as pervasive (with undocumented Asian immigrants) because the face of immigration is Latino, even though there are high numbers of Asian immigrants.”

New Asian enrollment likely to get tougher

According to the modeling from UCLA and UC Berkeley, there are an estimated 370,000 Asians in Covered California’s pool of potential enrollees. As of Feb. 28, slightly more than 160,000 had enrolled. Some advocates wonder if the better-educated people are the ones who have enrolled, whether Covered California has reached, as Doreena Wong puts it, the “low-lying fruit.”

“As we continue on, it might be more and more challenging and take more effort to reach those who have been discouraged from enrolling or who have had bad experiences,” Wong said.

This story is part of a reporting partnership between KQED, NPR and Kaiser Health News.

5 Responses to “Insurance Agents Key To California Success Enrolling Asian-Americans”

  1. gary d says:

    Across the country, HHS has failed to seek agent involvement in the enrollment process. The insurance carriers themselves have been just as complicit in this travesty. Throwing the agents under the bus at every opportunity in favor of untrained and mostly unprepared navigators. The latter cannot even take the applicant to a place of completion.

    Next open enrollment it is imperative that both the various government agencies and the insurance carriers not only seek but advertise and encourage agent participation. As this article points out, their involvement costs the consumers and the governments NOTHING! How may millions of dollars could have been saved if agents had been encouraged to participate in the process instead of ignored,

  2. As a Certified Insurance Agent for Covered California I have to agree with the comments of Gary D. Both the state exchange of Covered California and the carriers have done nothing but put road blocks in the path for agents to help existing and new clients.

    In California the agent enrollment system wasn’t even operational until November, it continues to have problems with agent delegation and the assistance from the exchange is abysmal. I know several agents that have thrown in the towel trying to enroll families through the exchange because of the numerous complications, long wait times to resolve issues and the ever dwindling compensation models.

    I’ve worked with numerous Chinese and Vietnamese families that really want to do the right thing by getting their families covered with health insurance. But the work doesn’t end with enrollment. There is still advocacy issues that the agent must undertake to ensure these families get the care they are paying for by finding the right doctors, additional education on how the health plan works and fixing billing issues from the carriers.

    When all the Certified Enrollment Counselors and Navigators have packed their bags and have gone on to look for the next government grant opportunity, agents will still be present to help their clients. We need to develop a system of health consumer advocates and not an army of “order takers” commonly know as enrollment assisters.

  3. Sheldon Weisgrau says:

    Gary D and Kevin Knauss are correct that agents can be an effective outlet to get consumers enrolled and that more emphasis could be placed on informing consumers about the availability of agents. However, agents are complicit in the problem.

    Here in Kansas, much of the anti-ACA backlash and misinformation about the law has come from the agent community. And rather than seeking ways to support and work with navigators, the organized agents’ lobby has pushed for legislation that would effectively criminalize navigators and other assisters. This does not apply to all agents, of course. But agents have certainly contributed more than their fair share to the political nonsense surrounding this law.

    There are 45+ million uninsured in the U.S. and 360,000 in Kansas. Surely there’s enough clients to go around so that agents, navigators, and other assisters all have plenty to do.

  4. Jean C. says:

    I wholeheartedly agree with Kevin Knauss.

  5. Pam says:

    Insurance agents key to California success? Huh? Before Obamacare, weren’t insurance agents the same people making huge profits by scamming consumers into buying health health insurance policies that were only good if you didn’t get sick? Before Obamacare, weren’t these the same shysters that had absolutely no conscience selling healthcare policies that would automatically cancel at the first sign of illness or injury? Talk about the fox guarding the hen house! I wouldn’t trust an health insurance agent as far as I can spit! Nothing but a bunch of bums!

Share